For what it's worth...
Rutgers *has* a post-bacc program. But I just finished it at Rutgers/Newark, and there is no appreciable difference between being a "post-bacc" and just taking the required courses as a non-matriculated student. Seriously. None whatsoever. I had no standing at the school, no assistance in choosing or getting into my classes, and no guidance in the MCAT or in the applications process. It was abysmal from that standpoint.
However, if it's cheaper for you--and it certainly is cheaper than either NYU or Columbia's programs--then you can certainly get what you need from it. You just have to figure things out for yourself and not expect guidance.
Hunter College has a program as well, if you're in the city.