JONM:
As an undergrad, I was NOT required to have a medical dictionary. I know about Stedman's and in fact have one but have never heard of Dorland. I hope that doesn't hurt my ability to become a good physician. I'm sorry you went to a graduate school where you were forbidden to ask questions. I went to a school where professors encouraged people to speak up if they didn't understand the material. I hope that doesn't make my program "less" than yours. I payed tuition to be taught. If I wanted to learn in the manner you describe, I could have saved my money, gone to a library and read, and when I didn't understand something, email someone who could explain it.
In terms of asking for help, I think anyone who is willing to do so has a great attribute. It means that he/she is wiiling to admit that he/she is lacking in some manner or in this case, doesn't know everything (no offense Edgar). Too often people are afraid to seek help because of embarassment, perceived weakness by others, or insecurity. What happens? In the most extreme case, suicide. Obviously, that's not going to happen in this case. My point is that I applaud anyone who seeks help and we as future physicians should jump at any opportunity to do so. Isn't that why we chose medicine as a career, to HELP OTHERS? You may think that you will succeed on your own in medical school and if that's the case, then great. However, many of your classmates will need assistance on occasion and I hope you will find it in your heart to help them. If not, at least turn them away without attacking them.
DOGBOY:
It sounds like you've been privelaged to have access to great textbooks that explain everything clearly. Good for you! However, most of us aren't so lucky and nearly all our texts are lacking in some manner. Why did you assume that Edgar hadn't researched his question already? Don't you think that it's possible that he did and simply didn't come up with an answer suitable for his purposes? I certainly didn't think he asked because he was being a lazy ass.
I think you should go watch Bambi. Fast-forward to the scene where Bambi is talking to Thumper and his Mom. To give a quick summary of the events, Thumper says something to Bambi which wasn't very nice and for which his mother quickly admonished him. The lesson Thumper learned was (paraphrased): if you don't have something nice or helpful to say, don't say it. By this I mean, don't make rude, hurtful, personal, and insensitive comments. This does not preclude you from making a statement that would force someone to face reality but do it in a manner that helps them and does not make them automatically tune you out. In terms of your comments to Gregory, why did you single him out? When he commented about the attacks on Edgar, he did not refer to any one specific person though it was obvious to whom it was directed. Yet, still no specific names. In addition, his request was completely justified whereas yours, which contained personal attacks, were not. All you need to do was state that we should all be free to post what we want. Why tell him to stay in Florida?
In conclusion, if you feel compelled to attack other premeds, go to Princeton Review's site. You can have a blast. I'll even make it easy for you.
discuss.review.com/forums/index.cfm?CFID=1250696&CFTOKEN=992&CFApp=16&
This site was created with the intention of providing a good resource for premeds, medical students (DO and MD), and I guess dental students as well. If our desire to limit comments to helpful and non-attacking ones makes us "goody-goodies," then I will be proud to change my SOMA name to "Goody-Goody."
[This message has been edited by justwannabadoc (edited 03-19-99).]